The Grand Mother and Grumpy have been able to get by with just 500 gallons of fuel oil to keep the Castle at an arguably comfortable temperature during the "winter" months here in King County. Usually Grumpy has kept the furnace turned "OFF" until the first of October and then turns it back to "OFF" when the first of May rolls around the next Spring. This past heating season seemed to be longer and colder (where is Al Gore when you need him!?) so the furnace remained "ON" well past the first of May. But the morning of May 15th found the Grand Mother and Grumpy shivering in bed: no heat today! We were out of fuel!!
Now the Grand Mother is adept at circumventing the frugal (stingy!?) habits of the Master of the Castle, however, and on those mornings was usually found in the kitchen, leisurely reading the morning paper -- with the oven door wide open and the oven turned to "toasty warm". Grumpy knew better than to start an argument about how this was defeating the purpose of our conservative heating lifestyle. He is still visualizing Lemon Meringue Pies in his future.
When the Grand Mother and Grumpy arrived home in mid-July, we found a fuel delivery statement on the door. The total cost for 500 gallons of fuel oil: $2505!! A review of the heat pump trade study was mandated!
Grumpy has been enamored of heat pump technology since he studied Mechanical Engineering at the School of Mines in South Dakota. He realized that, by "extracting" the heat from ordinary outside air (or, even better, from a lake or from ground water!) the effectiveness of the energy used to operate the compressor of the heat pump would be multiplied many times (This multiplying factor is called
Heating
Specific
Performance
Factor -- HSPF. Indeed, modern air-to-air heat pumps produce more than nine times the heat energy available in the home compared to the electrical energy they expend.
Grumpy's updated trade study for the Castle revealed the following:
1) Total heat energy used during typical year (500 gallons of fuel oil @ 128,50 Btu/gal.) in 85% efficiency furnace: 54,591,250 Btu. Cost: $2500 per year (and probably going higher!).
2) Cost of electricity@$0.08/kwh to operated heat pump: $143 per year (assuming HSPF of 9.0). Cost of electricity to operate heat pump for 120% of "typical" year: $772 per year (assuming HSPF of 2.0).
3) Initial cost of heat pump installed: $8,000 (includes factory rebate and IRS energy credit).
4) Years to "break even": 3.76 years ("typical" heating year, assuming cost of capital @ 8% APR).
5) Years to "break even" @ 120% "typical" year: 5.46 years.

The conclusion to which the Grand Mother and Grumpy arrived was to have a four ton capacity heat pump installed (~49,000 Btu/hr.). Pictured at right is the main unit, with other needed parts stacked on the left. This installation should provide all of our heat requirements on all days except those when the outside air temperature is at or below 32 degrees Fahrenheit; then the oil furnace will "kick in" to supply the additional heat needed.
Grumpy wired a new 35 ampere, 240 volt AC circuit to an outside weather proof disconnect, shown next to the door above the main unit, and had cleared a "path" for the liquid refrigerant lines and system control wires to be run between the heat pump compressor (located on the lower-level patio) to the existing oil furnace where the condensor (heating)/evaporator (cooling) heat exchanger would be mounted inside the existing (or modified) hot air bonnet.
Six HVAC (Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning) contractors were contacted to bid on the project. Ultimately only one put in a reasonable bid (two or three quickly concluded that their proposed units could not be fit inside the bonnet on the existing oil furnace (a definite "must" to validate the trade study); one of the contractors, [name withheld to protect the guilty!], bid a choice of adding a gas- or oil-burning furnace in order to "fit" their 3-ton unit into the headroom available.

The winning contractor (Hayes Heating and Cooling of Renton) was given a contract to install their proposed 4-ton heat pump. [When he was clearing the pathway for the electrical and refrigerant lines, Grumpy noticed a magnetic "sticker" placed on the furnace. It had been placed there by the Hayes Heating & Cooling salesman, Tim, when he was checking dimensions for the proposal. Grumpy joked that he thinks that this sticker "frightened" away the other would-be bidders!] The installers, Kirtan and Ryan (see photo at left), arrived with the equipment early Monday morning and went right to work. Soon they were drilling holes for the electrical and refrigerant lines to pass between the floor joists from the outside of the house to ceiling space in the furnace room.

Drilling through the outside triple-joist, the big 3 or 4 inch hole cutter ran into a nail --
or ten!! -- emitting a loud, rumbling chatter that shook the house and elicited the facial expression of horror seen on the Grand Mother's face in the photo to the right. "
They are destroying my house!!" she moaned.

Where other contractors' salesmen couldn't conceive of the possibilities for innovative modifications that could be used to accommodate the evaporator/condenser unit within the constraints of the existing bonnet, Hayes' installers made quick [well, it turned out to be "not-so-quick"!] and neat work of fashioning this modified bonnet for our existing furnace. Although, as the photo at left indicates, some detail work remains to be done. This two-day job turned into a four day job, so Grumpy has decided to go ahead and post this now as a status report rather than wait another day.
We look forward to a more comfortably warm home starting
before the first of October this Fall and continuing
past the first of May next Spring. And no more "suffering" from the too-hot days and nights like we experienced this past Summer -- in between the colder-than-usual days and nights, that is!
Watch for subsequent posts as the coming heating season proceeds, with actual electrical and oil consumption data, as Grumpy boasts of the cost savings supporting his engineering trade study summarized above. His crowing may be almost tolerable!